Allegra Cole or Allegra Coleman

Esquire magazine's November 1996 cover featured Allegra Coleman, the hot new star said to be taking Hollywood by storm. "Forget Gwyneth, Forget Mira," the cover trumpeted. "Here's Hollywood's next Dream Girl."

The feature article inside gushed about the buzz building around her. David Schwimmer, star of Friends, was said to be her on-again, off-again boyfriend, although he was getting some competition from Quentin Tarantino who had apparently dumped Mira Sorvino to go out with her. It was even rumored that Woody Allen had completely overhauled his next movie so that she could star in it. "The real thing," the article gushed. "She has it."

However, the source of Allegra's appeal was not entirely clear. "Her nature is spongy and luminescent," the self-help guru Deepak Chopra was quoted as saying by way of explanation. Excerpts from her diary didn't clarify matters either. "I am having thoughts," one entry read. "Really getting into thinking." She seemed to be a mystery. Or, as Allegra herself put it, "It's like Stonehenge, you know? The biggest mystery, totally unsolved."

Nevertheless, Hollywood was intrigued. After Esquire ran the article, the magazine began receiving calls from talent scouts, desperate to get in touch with the new star. But not all readers were taken with Allegra. The St. Louis Post-Dispatch denounced Esquire for celebrating her obvious brainless vapidity.

As it turned out, Allegra really was a mystery, principally because she didn't exist. Esquire had made her up as a spoof of the fawning puffery that most magazines shower on movie stars. The woman shown on the cover and in the photos inside was a little- known actress called Ali Larter. After posing as Allegra Coleman, Larter went on to develop a real career in Hollywood, acting in movies such as House on Haunted Hill, American Outlaws, and Legally Blonde.